Wolfenstein: The New Order Review: The Ultimate Blend of Story and Action

The question "What if the Nazis won World War II?" is perhaps the most frequently pondered alternate history scenario. It’s an intriguing topic because, while wars are often driven by complex motives, the Third Reich is synonymous with unmitigated evil, exemplified by its brutal propaganda, aggressive military campaigns, and the horrific genocide of millions.

Not every alternate history WWII shooter lives up to expectations (looking at you, Turning Point: Fall of Liberty). However, Wolfenstein: The New Order stands out not merely for its setting in a fictional Nazi-dominated future, but for the fresh perspective it brings to the table. While it includes familiar symbols like Swastikas and Iron Crosses, its narrative and gameplay offer something uniquely compelling.

In The New Order, Nazi Germany has not only emerged victorious in World War II but has also extended its oppressive rule across the globe by 1960. This game presents a world where the Nazis continue their reign of terror, eradicating their foes and purging society of those they deem unworthy. What struck me was the high-quality writing that imbues the game with authenticity. The cutscenes are particularly impressive, filled with subtle details that enhance their realism—character gestures, the flick of a cigarette, and the weight of emotions all come to life in a way that draws players in.

Returning to the fray is the series' protagonist, BJ Blazkowicz, who is more nuanced than ever before. The game opens with a flashback to 14 years prior, where Blazkowicz is portrayed as a brute; however, by the time the main campaign kicks off in 1960, he has evolved into a seasoned, reflective character, shaped by the harsh realities of a world dominated by Nazis. His journey, along with that of memorable characters like the villainous General Deathshead and the courageous Caroline Becker, makes the story resonate on an emotional level.

In terms of performance, The New Order generally runs smoothly, though players may encounter occasional texture pop-ins and some audio mixing issues that obscure well-delivered lines. Visually, the game impresses, showcasing beautifully rendered environments—from the terrifyingly grand Neo-Berlin to serene, picturesque scenes in the wilderness, such as Blazkowicz’s first glimpse of the sky after years of confinement.

Gameplay-wise, The New Order adheres to familiar shooter mechanics. Players have access to a standard arsenal, including knives, pistols, and futuristic weapons like laser rifles that reinforce its alternate history premise. While gunplay is satisfying, the dual-wielding mechanic feels cumbersome in intense firefights, which can detract from the overall experience.

Stealth elements introduce an engaging dynamic to the combat, allowing players to sneak through expansive maps and execute silent takedowns. While this adds depth, it also reveals inconsistencies in enemy AI, which can sometimes seem oblivious to the chaos around them. This can create a paradox where stealth becomes both an advantage and a detriment.

One of the standout features is the skill progression system. Instead of traditional leveling up, skills are unlocked through in-game achievements, such as scoring headshots or executing stealth kills. This approach adds a layer of depth and makes the experience feel distinct from other shooters.

Exploring the game’s diverse environments reveals a chilling vision of what a victorious Nazi regime might have achieved—complete with a space program and advanced weaponry. While some areas might feel sparse in terms of activity, the attention to detail in crafting this oppressive world is commendable. However, the repetitive collection mechanics—pressing a button to gather health, armor, and ammunition—can sometimes disrupt immersion.

Where The New Order truly excels is in its narrative and character development. It weaves together elements of alternate history in a way that feels plausible, despite the outrageous scenarios. The game deftly integrates real-life references to Nazi atrocities, providing a sobering backdrop that adds weight to the experience. From harrowing depictions of forced labor camps to poignant insights into the regime’s treatment of marginalized groups, these moments enhance the game’s emotional impact.

For those playing on last-gen consoles like the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360, the experience remains largely consistent with the newer versions, though visual fidelity suffers, and players may encounter technical hiccups, particularly with audio. The PS3 version even presented issues requiring multiple installations to function properly, which is noteworthy.

Verdict

Wolfenstein: The New Order masterfully blends traditional shooter gameplay with strong writing and relatable characters. Its grounded approach to the often exaggerated alternate history narrative sets it apart, making the 10-to-12 hour campaign an engaging journey that prompts deeper reflection. With a pivotal choice early in the game that encourages multiple playthroughs, the story effectively elevates what could have been a typical shooter into something far more meaningful.